Magnet Hospitals = Nursing Excellence & Better Patient Experiences

By Sondra Forsyth

A study published in October 2015 in Health Services Research shows that Magnet hospitals nationally that are accredited for nursing excellence have higher patient ratings of care than other hospitals. The study, led by Dr. Witkoski-Stimpfel at New York University College of Nursing and the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research, suggests that hospitals seeking to improve patient satisfaction and qualify for new financial incentives would be well advised to consider investing in nursing excellence.

A release from New York University quotes Amy Witkoski-Stimpfel, PhD, RN as saying, “One straightforward strategy to improve patients’ experience, and thus improve the performance scores, involves registered nurses. Research has shown that patients’ experience with hospital care is significantly related to whether or not hospitals are well-resourced with respect to nursing, as nurses are the ones providing the most direct patient care in hospitals.”

For hospital management and policy makers, despite the evidence showing that patient outcomes are better in hospitals with good nurse work environments, it is not always clear how to translate this evidence into practice and to reform work environments. Dr. Witkoski-Stimpfel points to the Magnet recognition program as a method to implement improvements in nurse work environments.

“Magnet recognized hospitals have consistently been associated with superior patient outcomes, including lower patient mortality and higher nurse job satisfaction,” she says. “And, with an estimated pool of over $1 billion for performance incentives in 2014 fiscal year alone and increases in subsequent years, there is good reason for hospital leaders to be motivated to improve their patients’ experience.”

The study evaluated the performance of 212 Magnet hospitals in comparison to that of 212 matched non-Magnet hospitals, by assessing their Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) survey. Designed to evaluate patients’ short-term hospital care experience, the HCAHPS survey constitutes thirty percent of a hospital’s total performance score for reimbursement by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

“Our study is one of the most comprehensive studies to date to demonstrate an association between Magnet recognition and patients’ satisfaction with their hospital care using the HCAHPS survey,” said Linda H Aiken, Director of Penn’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research. “Patients who received care in Magnet hospitals reported signi?cantly greater satisfaction with their care.”

“The Magnet recognition process emphasizes innovation; evidence-based, patient-centered care; and a collaborative culture, making these likely contributors to the more favorable patient care experience demonstrated in our results,” said co-investigator, Matthew D McHugh from Penn Nursing’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research. “For example, when nurses work in an environment that is well resourced and management is supportive of nurses, nurses are able to spend time assessing and educating patients and families, which may explain the better communication, pain control, and medication explanation scores that we observed.”

The evidence suggests that nursing excellence is key to achieving good hospital ratings from patients, says Dr. Witkoski-Stimpfel.